Pretty Little Liars Cast's Best Post-Series Roles, Ranked

10. Lucy Hale in "Fantasy Island" (2020)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 48%
Lucy Hale switches gears completely in this horror adaptation of the classic TV show. She plays Melanie Cole, a woman who arrives on Fantasy Island with the wish to get revenge on her high-school bully. Sounds simple, right? Wrong. The island makes her fantasy a reality, letting her torture her bully in a controlled environment.

But, as Melanie starts to feel remorse, things take a dark turn. Other fantasies on the island start to overlap with hers, leading to dangerous and horrifying outcomes.

9. Troian Bellisario in "Where'd You Go, Bernadette" (2019)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 50%
Troian plays Becky, a researcher in Antarctica who becomes an unexpected friend to the missing Bernadette. Now, the movie is about Bernadette, an agoraphobic mom who goes missing, but Becky plays a vital part in her rediscovery.

When Bernadette gets to Antarctica (it's a whole big thing involving family drama and a mid-life crisis), she meets Becky. The two bond while working together in harsh conditions, sharing meals in the canteen and trekking across the icy landscapes.

8. Shay Mitchell in "Dollface" (2019-present)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 58%
Shay Mitchell is back on the small screen, this time playing Stella Cole in "Dollface." The show is about Jules, who after being dumped by her long-term boyfriend, realizes she's lost all her female friends.

Stella is one of those friends, a free-spirited, fun-loving woman who seems to have it all but is really scrambling to keep her life together. She helps Jules reconnect with their other friends, Madison and Izzy, as they rekindle their friendships through various.

7. Sasha Pieterse in "The Honor List" (2018)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 60%
Sasha Pieterse plays Isabella, one of four high school friends who drift apart after a falling out. During their final year, Isabella dies unexpectedly. Her death prompts her friends to complete a bucket list they created together freshman year.

As they work through the list — which includes items like getting a tattoo and breaking into their school — they start to learn more about why their friendship fell apart and how much Isabella had been keeping from them.

6. Ashley Benson in "Spring Breakers" (2013)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 68%
From Hanna Marin to a spring breaker — now, this is one hell of a shift! In "Spring Breakers," Ashley Benson plays Brit, one of four college girls desperate for a wild spring break adventure. Along with her friends, she robs a restaurant to fund their trip to Florida. Once there, they get arrested during a party but are bailed out by a local rapper and drug dealer named Alien (James Franco).

Alien takes them under his wing, and they get involved in his criminal activities. Brit and her friend Cotty take to this life pretty quickly.

5. Sasha Pieterse in "Inherent Vice" (2014)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 74%
Sasha Pieterse, our beloved Alison DiLaurentis, joined a star-studded cast in this mystery drama.

Set in the '70s, Pieterse plays Japonica Fenway, a runaway teen who gets mixed up in a complicated plot involving her ex-lover, detective Doc Sportello. Doc is hired to investigate the disappearance of his former girlfriend's new lover, but things get twisty when Japonica appears and seems to be involved in the shady dealings of a mysterious organization.

4. Troian Bellisario in "Feed" (2017)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 75%
We knew Troian Bellisario was a powerhouse from her days as Spencer Hastings, but in "Feed," she really shows her chops. The movie is about Olivia (Bellisario) and her twin brother, Matthew, who share everything, including a deep emotional connection. After Matthew dies in a car accident, Olivia spirals into an eating disorder.

As she goes through her daily life, including going to school and hanging out with friends, she hallucinates that her brother is still with her, guiding her actions and choices. But he's not the supportive ghost you'd hope for. Instead, he becomes a manifestation of her eating disorder.

3. Ashley Benson in "Her Smell" (2018)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 84%
Ashley Benson joins a rock band as Roxie Rotten in "Her Smell," a story about the rise and fall of a '90s punk band. The movie revolves around the band's frontwoman, Becky Something, who is self-destructive and out of control.

Roxie, along with the other band members, struggles to handle the chaos Becky creates. She's always there during the band's backstage meltdowns, their failed recording sessions, and eventual breakup. Ultimately, Roxie has to make a choice between her loyalty to a friend and the toxic environment that's consuming them all.

2. Shay Mitchell in "You" (2018-present)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 91%
You've got to admit, Shay Mitchell knows how to pick roles with drama and suspense. In the TV series "You," she plays Peach Salinger, an affluent New Yorker and best friend to Guinevere Beck. Joe, the main character, is a bookstore manager who becomes obsessively in love with Beck.

Peach is suspicious of Joe from the get-go. Being the protective and somewhat manipulative friend, she does everything to keep Joe away from Beck. Her posh apartment becomes a backdrop for some of the most tension-filled scenes, as Joe breaks in multiple times, and Peach becomes increasingly more convinced that someone is watching her.

1. Lucy Hale in "Katy Keene" (2020-2021)
Rotten Tomatoes score: 91%
Remember Aria Montgomery? Well, Lucy Hale took on a whole different character in "Katy Keene," a "Riverdale" spinoff.

Hale plays Katy Keene, an aspiring fashion designer working in a department store while trying to make her dreams come true. She shares an apartment with her friends, who also have big ambitions in the Big Apple. Her story arc mostly centers around her juggling her demanding job, her complicated love life, and her goal of becoming a famous designer.

It's like a mix of "The Devil Wears Prada" and "Friends," but for the younger crowd.